Tuesday, April 28, 2015

Psychoanalytical Lens (Motherhood in Beloved: A Psychological Reading)

       During the time period this book is being set in we can clearly see that African American people are seen as only property. And this kept on happening even after the slaves were freed, afterwards they were seen as enemies. This book really portrays this, and according to the reading this is a book about a freed slaved that is a mother and has to enjoy her freedom however looses it by living in 124. And it also explains how the psychoanalytical lens plays into the book and how does it affect the characters of the book, such as Sethe. Sethe is the main character of the book and the one that is the most affected throughout the book by arrivals and decisions. The psychoanalytical is a lens that can be very confusing since it is defining and explaining what the characters are really thinking and, and why they think in certain ways. According to the reading the psychoanalytical point of view in the book, shows a lot of motherhood and mother like behaviors that occur throughout the book as well and we cans see them too. For example, when Sethe believes that Beloved is her reincarnated daughter since she hears her singing a song that Beloved use to sing to her kid s to go to sleep. Another great example, is when Beloved starts to act more like the mother of Sethe towards the end of the book since she begins to drain all of Sethe's energy.
       The psychoanalytical lens has also helped me to realize many hidden desires of the characters, from Sethe's sexual desires, to what Beloved really wanted in 124. And I have also learned what is the thoughts of the characters and how do they become part of the puzzle that has been created by the events that have occurred in 124. Many of the events of this book are almost as though they were mere dreams, and we begin to see this towards the end however they are not it is just that the fact that the supernatural has mixed with Sethe's undesirable life has mixed up many of the people that are around Sethe. Monologues start to really show towards the end of the book, and those strongly relate to the psychoanalytical portion of this book since three specific characters are expressing how they feel about each other. Sethe being one of them, feels as though she must protect both Denver and Beloved since she considers both of them her children. On the hand, Denver wants to protect Beloved from Sethe since Denver knows what happened to her sister and does not want to loose Beloved. But Beloved wants to get really close to Sethe, since it would pretty much give Beloved her everything back and would be back to how she apparently was. All of these monologues demonstrate to use the character's true motivations and some desires that may not be the best to some people, however that didn't stop Beloved from doing what she wanted to achieve.

Sister Love( Responding and Reflecting #2)


57eb2399767a692b5b20500a82f08d8d.jpgSomething that I have learned from Beloved so far as reading it through psychoanalytic lens would connect in some ways because when reading the relationship that Beloved and Denver had connected to me.  Denver was like a mother figure to Beloved. She would be there for when Beloved was upset and she missed Sethe. The relationship that those two have is pretty strong. This relates to my lens because there are questions like “Who has a difficult mother?”.  A difficult mother, which are a group of teenage girls,  presents challenges and are capable of engaging with a child more than an adult. This is partly true with me because I feel like I do have a role as a mom to my siblings, but my mom is involved in being their for us but not not really engaged to really be comfortable in truly knowing us. Since we spend a lot of time together I probably know her more than my mom because I take the time to figure out how she feel in school and I do everything that I can in order to  defend my sister. This is because when my mom would be out working late, I would be the one in charge. I remember always being there for my sister, for when she needed help with math. She has always struggled with math, but I would do everything that I could in order to help my sister. I feel as if I was a mother figure to her because when she get hurt I am there for her to feel better and there are time things that they say about her just because she a little different breaks my heart. That is why I love how this book shows me how sister love is the best type of relationship that a girl can have because you’d be confident to know what's wrong and what she needs help in anything. Having a good relationship with your sibling is as strong as a mother and daughter relationship.

Sorrow - A Personal Reflection

Growing up, my mom has always told me that "everybody has a sad story to tell". AS a young girl, I never fully appreciated or understood this thought. It took me a long time to see past my own tragedies, disappointment, fears, and anxieties. However, I have been more able to extend my own sad feelings to others and have found comfort and strength in realizing that all individuals are joint by same emotions and natural fears and tendencies.


I find that Denver perfectly sums up the feeling of loneliness the most people experience at some point, usually many times. Denver grows up in almost impossible circumstances and survives. She goes through an ocean of emotional distress but ultimately fights through her problems and becomes a stronger person. Denver transforms drastically with the departure and the loss of her brothers and Baby Suggs, which causes her to become isolated and self centered. Denver feels like she is detached from the world after her tragic losses. She even tells Sethe that she "can't live here. Nobody speaks to us. Nobody comes by. Boys don't like me. Girls don't either". 

I have not experienced a serious loss in my family like Denver, however I have experienced loss in other ways. In my freshman year of high school my parents had separated and my mom was forced out of our home. I resented my parents for almost two straight years, confused by the changes and my own emotions. I have witnessed my mom make herself ill from guilt and loneliness. And just this year I watched my dad be hospitalized and bed-sick for eight full months. My parents have not yet departed, but many times have I felt as if they were already gone. 

These experiences, make me and Denver alike, in times when"solitude had made [me] secretive - self manipulated". "Years of haunting" has "dulled" me in many ways and has made me numb to many ill experiences. (117) I believe that the harsh and seemingly impossible tragedies that I feel mirrored in Denver, curate a superego that judges my own self and others deeply and harshly. I believe also that since everyone has a sad story to tell that each person in this world can and does make judgments particularly based on the tragedy they have endured. 

Reading Beloved and connected deeply to Denver, I believe that it is possible to find relief in sharing with others during times of extreme sadness. And that it is possible to choose your own attitude or judgment in any given circumstance, when you harness enough strength and will power. 


Love for your child


670px-Stand-up-to-Your-Mother-in-a-Respectful-Manner-Step-6.jpgIn Beloved, something that I have learned as a result of reading it through Psychoanalytic Lens was the fact that I got to learn how a mothers love towards her child is unconditional and how a mother would love her child so much that they would do anything in order to protect them and keeping them getting hurt. This book has completely made me open my eyes and see the perspective of a mother and how she shows to much love and that makes me see my life personally because I used to only saw the bad side of my mother because my mom would everything she can from going far away for college and go out with my friends. My decisions are mostly being made by my mom. She decides whether I can go out-of-state for college, whether I can go to anywhere with my friends. I would honestly just would see how I have no freedom and all my choices are being made instead of me actually making those decision. Reading this book help me see the reason why a mother does what she does. My mom you can say does everything she can to always be by her side, and always keep me at home so she see everything that I am doing. Relating this back to my close reading blogs I would take Paul D’s side because in this situation a mothers love is dangerous because once we leave our mothers side they are heartbroken and mother just think about you and worry about you once you're in college. That is why Paul D says that you should only “love just a little bit... [so you have] a little love left over for the next one”. By a mother loving her children a little bit would help prevent her from getting hurt because she would be able to love her other children and also be their to support them for when they need her.

Baby Suggs or Baby Jesus? (Blog Entry #2)




" 'Here,' she said, 'in this here place, we flesh; flesh that weeps, laughs; flesh that dances on bare feet in grass. Love it. Love it hard. Yonder they do not love your flesh. They despise it. They don't love your eyes; they'd just as soon pick em out. No more do they love the skin on your back. Yonder they flay it. And O my people they do not love your hands. Those they only use, tie, bind, chop off and leave empty. Love your hands! Love them. Raise them up and kiss them. Touch others with them, pat them together, stroke them on your face 'cause they don't love that either. You got to love it, you! And no, they ain't in love with your mouth. Yonder, out there, they will see it broken and break it again. What you say out of it they will not heed. What you scream for it they do not hear. What you put into it to nourish your body they will snatch away and give you leavins instead. No, they don't love your mouth. You got to love it. This is the flesh I'm talking about here. Flesh that needs to be loved. Feet that need to rest and dance; backs that need support; shoulders that need arms, strong arms I'm telling you. And O my people, out yonder, hear me they do not love your neck unnoosed and straight. So love your neck;" (104)

In physics, we are all taught that nothing is ever destroyed, it is just recycled and reused in another form or state. Love is a concept that you can't see what it is, and most people have to search for it, but we know it is out there. Love is a source of power, that is fundamental for survival in any situation. Whether it is the Holocaust, a genocide, or slavery, love is what gives people and especially slaves in this instance, the ability to strive and move on. Unfortunately for the slaves, their love and source of power has been drained to an unfathomably low amount. Through constant slavery, rape, inequality, and abuse and oppression from white people, African-Americans have been given the perception that they have little to live for during this time period. Luckily for African Americans in The Clearing where Baby Suggs was preaching and teaching her ways, there is hope for slaves to be able to gain back their power and desire to live a normal life and gain a sense of self-identity. Similar to what the Nazis did with the Jews where they stripped them of their clothes and shaved their heads to make all of the Jews indistinguishable, whites did the same things to slaves where they stripped them of their sense of identity by breaking down their souls and determination and stripping them of their power. In this passage, Baby Suggs is doing a very important job and a job that no one would have predicted she would have, she is preaching to slaves about how to gain back their sense of identity. Baby Suggs is a very influential character throughout the book but in this flashback, Baby Suggs screams and yells to "love your hands! Love them. Raise them up and kiss them," (104) because since slavery has ended on paper and the aftermaths are still taking place, slaves need to re-learn how to achieve their own identity again which is their source of power. Baby Suggs makes it very clear while teaching this bible-like-lesson to the slaves similar to how Moses lead the Jews from slave-ridden Egypt. I also saw a Jesus-like character in Baby Suggs and this presents the reoccurring theme in Beloved that Sethe believes in that nothing is ever destroyed, it just comes back in a different form. In this case, the power and identity that slaves had was physically and psychologically broken down and Baby Suggs is doing her best to build up and reconstruct the crushed and damaged souls that white men have fractured and cement the principal idea that you need to love yourself because no one else is going to love you unless you love yourself first. Through a Marxist lens, the reader can see that the language and tone of Baby Suggs in the Clearing is messiah-like and draws comparisons to leaders like Jesus and Moses.

Dangerous Love

“Risky, thought Paul D, very risky. For a used-to-be-slave woman to love anything that much was dangerous, especially if it was her children she had settled on to love. The best thing, he knew, was to love just a little bit; everything, just a little bit, so when they broke its back, or shove it in a croaker sack, well, maybe you’d have a little love left over for the next one.”

The significance of this quote is that loving someone so much is dangerous for a mother because once that child of yours has left or has been taken away the mother's heart would be heartbroken and she’d feel torn to know that she might not see him/her ever again. Here Paul D feels that to love like Sethe is in fact dangerous because she is giving all of her love to Denver. Paul D feels that one should only love a child just a “little” so that way if Denver were to leave and be independent, Sethe would have room “leftover” to love Paul D.
4490110-lg.jpg

What is love truly? Is love just one thing or is it seen in multiple ways? This quote reveals how Sethe’s love is unconditional towards Denver and how she is the “best thing’ that has ever happened to her. In this quote the are different points of views because Paul D notices that Sethe’s love is so “much [that it’s] dangerous”. But he doesn’t approve of her love because he feels as if one should just love a “little bit [because]...maybe [there would be] a little leftover”. This give one an misinterpretation that Paul D might be jealous because Sethe give more attention to Denver than to him. This could be that he want Sethe to show him some love and not so much to Denver.

In this quote, love can be interpreted in many different ways. Based on this quote, it contains a mania, which is an obsessive and jealous love, and agape, which is an altruistic love because Sethe cares deeply for Denver that she is not willing for her to be unprotected and Paul D has jealousy because he sees how Sethe is giving Denver all of the attention, and he fears she might not have love leftover for him.  

A Fabricated Reality: Sethe's Motherhood



"Motherhood in Toni Morrison's Beloved: A Psychological Reading" by Sandra Mayfield offers a complex illustration of Sethe's "risky" motherhood and explains the parts of Sethes's early life that "led her to view her position as a mother as a meaningful vocation". Mayfield describes several issues of injustice in society such as sexism, racism, and objectification that would lead any woman towards feelings of loneliness and "Desire" for "connection". By acknowledging and rationalizing the historical context it enlightens readers about the larger issues that contribute to the making of Sethe's motherhood, her greatest struggle and triumph.




Mayfield describes that Sethe's powerful calling to be a mother, a good mother, was initially sparked during the traumatic experience of "witnessing her mother's death". The severe isolation she experienced at an age before twelve, is compared to and further explained by the "external break" philosophy originated by Jacques Lacan. Lacan believed that children develop several images and narratives based on their human interactions in the part of the mind that her termed the "imaginary". The imaginary is the space that the child a sense of self and the basis of narratives that can only be understood by the child themselves. The "imaginary" is very similar in theory to Sigmund Freud, the godfather of psychology, and his belief that the unconscious and personal desires are influenced by childhood events.

It is also pointed out that Sethe's experience as a young slave woman, particularly the sexual assaults, had grounded her passion for motherhood in a commitment to "give her [children] a better life than she had experienced". This too, adds to the her personal devotion to achieve a passionate motherhood. In fact, it can even be argued that, in terms of Lacanian analysis, Sethe wanted to be the object of desire of her own children, just as they were hers.



Mayfield's early reflections on maternal memory-never good enough to remember the good (especially the mentioning of when Baby Suggs agonizes about all the details about her eight children she cannot remember) and never bad enough to forget the pain-are replaced later on with maternal rememory which is like weather . It is always there, "not the breath of the disremembered to be accounted for, but wind in the eaves, or spring ice thawing too quickly. Just weather." Maternal rememory, once Sethe fully experiences it in the novel, may indeed be capable of performing a task deemed impossible in the beginning of the novel-to remember the beautiful trees of Sweet Home and the bodies hanging from them. As the story of the past embodied in Beloved emerges, such distinctions and separations vanish and no one position remains comfortably distinguishable, categorizable in schoolteacher-style into separate characteristics . A series of counter narratives, of counter families, offers a metonymic escape route out of the master narrative
of family and Motherhood.