The arrival of Paul D to 124, affected Denver in a very negative way since it wasn't the arrival Denver wanted. Compared to the arrival of Beloved, the arrival of Paul D was most likely one of the toughest things to handle due to the fact that Paul D had Sethe's support. So, Denver had to deal with the fact that she now has to live with Paul D in the same house and pretty much her step-dad. The way Denver handled it by asking him when he was going to leave and acting up really lead to the decision of pretty much hiding in her closet to space out and not get involved with Paul D.
Monday, April 27, 2015
Character's Impulsiveness and Decisions
The arrival of Paul D to 124, affected Denver in a very negative way since it wasn't the arrival Denver wanted. Compared to the arrival of Beloved, the arrival of Paul D was most likely one of the toughest things to handle due to the fact that Paul D had Sethe's support. So, Denver had to deal with the fact that she now has to live with Paul D in the same house and pretty much her step-dad. The way Denver handled it by asking him when he was going to leave and acting up really lead to the decision of pretty much hiding in her closet to space out and not get involved with Paul D.
Inner thoughts and desires
In the book I have found that there are many cases in which the characters take very abrupt actions, no matter what they're thinking in the inside. Whether is a good decision, a bad decision or something that is going to change the way they live or the way the progress throughout their lives. A very big event that changes a lot of how the characters, such as Sethe, Denver and Paul D, have to live is the arrival of Paul D. Since, right off the start Denver does not want Paul D to keep living with Sethe and herself. This puts Denver in a corner since her monther wants Paul D to stay, however there is a conflict between Paul D and Sethe and that also leads to Sethe thinking in many different ways. The arrival of Paul D gives Sethe many desires that have not been felt in many years, but it also begins a whole new argument within Sethe of does she want Paul D to live or not. Sethe really thinks about how she would become a brand new persons if she had sort-off a husband in the house, however probably deep inside she was thinking about how will Paul D joining Sethe and Denver's freedom affect the way Sethe will grow and wheter it would be a good thing or a bad thing. Judging by what has been going on with the trio, Sethe believes that she has made the right decision by allowing Paul D to stay with them.
However an even more important arrival to Sethe's home has to be the arrival of Beloved, who doesn't only come out of nowhere but goes straight towards Sehte's house and decides to stay. This mysterious character seems to be really attached to Sethe by reasons that nobody knows except for Beloved herself. This could mean that Beloved sees Sethe as almost a mother like figure that she wants to be with, and she also seems to treat Denver very well almost as though they were sisters. Maybe, Beloved's true desire is to join somebody's family and try to fit in to be safe from what she was escaping or she believes that she belonged to that family for a while. However her thoughts change about Paul D, maybe because he pushes her buttons at dinner. But, towards the begging there was this mood of envy or jealousy from Paul D towards this mysterious person, so much that he wanted to get rid of her. While Paul D believes that she is dangerous to Sethe and Denver because Beloved is a strange, maybe his true intention is to get rid of her because he fears as though the attention he was receiving from Sethe and Denver is being taken away.
Id, Ego, and the Superego
Reading the book in my lens which is psychoanalytical I have learned that there are many characters that many hidden thoughts, desires, and points of view. The fact that this book is very sexual related has allowed me to find much information about many of the characters such as Sethe, Paul D, and Halle. One of the main examples is when Sethe and Paul D sleep together one night, both of them were lead by their id which impulsed them to take action and react to what was going on. The ego which is a restrain to the id, reacted late or did not react at all and that is the reason why Sethe and Paul D slept together on that one night. The ego is the reason why many of our decision are not made, since the ego makes your brain think about what your id is trying to make you do and your ego makes sure you think things through and you make the right decision. In this book there are many occasions where the id and the ego, this is a great example of how the ego did not successfully counter the ego.
Another great way to demonstrate where the ego and the id both took action is when Sethe is getting her mil stolen and Halle is watching on top of the barn scared because he doesn't know how to help. This also demonstrates and opens up to conflicts, between Hallen and himself as well as Sethe and Hallen. The id and the ego really come in to play when Halle is watching because this time the ego was stronger than the id, and therefore decided that him not doing much about the problem was the best option for him. However this created a great conflict with himself that lead to him becoming crazy and loosing control of himself. Sethe developed a small conflict with him since she didn't see him anymore, later on when Paul D tells her it creates a even bigger conflict that took away all the lies from Sethe and how she felt about Halle.
Another great way to demonstrate where the ego and the id both took action is when Sethe is getting her mil stolen and Halle is watching on top of the barn scared because he doesn't know how to help. This also demonstrates and opens up to conflicts, between Hallen and himself as well as Sethe and Hallen. The id and the ego really come in to play when Halle is watching because this time the ego was stronger than the id, and therefore decided that him not doing much about the problem was the best option for him. However this created a great conflict with himself that lead to him becoming crazy and loosing control of himself. Sethe developed a small conflict with him since she didn't see him anymore, later on when Paul D tells her it creates a even bigger conflict that took away all the lies from Sethe and how she felt about Halle.
Thursday, April 16, 2015
Nothing Can be Forgotten(Close Reading #1)
“It’s so hard for me to believe in it. Some things go. Pass on. Some things just stay. I used to think it was my rememory. You know. Some things you forget. Other things you never do. But it’s not. Places, places are still there . If a house burns down, it’s gone, but the place--the picture of it--stays, and not just in my rememory, but out their, in the world. What I remember is a picture floating around out there outside my head. I mean, even if I don’t think it, even if I die, the picture of what I did, or knew, or saw is still out there. Right in the place where it happened,”
Significance:
This quote reveals that she has so many things in mind. So many memories and flashbacks that just can’t be “burns down,”. Memories will always remain alive. Sethe has so many memories that she just can’t forget. Her past will always be there and when someone comes across 124 they will relive that event. What happened in 124 will always be there it will always be talked about. It would be forgotten.People can often remember an event by placing themselves in the same context they were in when the event happened. Another things that is brought up is the fact that Sethe had lost her daughter and her 2 sons, she is living a life where she can’t forget her past.
Sethe is emotionally traumatized by both her loss of her children. The loss of children always hurt a mother and it shows how they can’t get over it and wish that their child was their. That is why in the book Sethe keep Denver close and tries to love her as much as she can. She would do anything to defended her. We probably wouldn't be able to understand how a mother feels in the inside, until one day it happens to us. In addition, Slavery can also not be forgotten because we still talk about it today. Slavery was a big issue because African Americans weren't seen a people they were seen as property. In this book slavery was already abolished but ex-slaves still didn't feel free because they weren't treated kindly, they weren't treated equally.
Tuesday, April 7, 2015
Close Reading #1
“Breathless with the excitement of seeing white people loose: doing magic, clowning, without heads or with two heads, twenty feet tall or two feet tall, weighing a ton, completely tattooed, eating glass, swallowing fire, spitting ribbons, twisted into knots, forming pyramids, playing with snakes and beating each other up.
All of this was advertisement, read by those who could and heard by those who could not, and the fact that none of it was true did not extinguish their appetite a bit. The barker called them and their children names (“Pickaninnies free!”) but the food on his vest and the hole in his pants rendered it fairly harmless. In any case it was a small price to pay for the fun they might not ever have again. Two pennies and an insult were well spent if it meant seeing the spectacle of white folks making a spectacle of themselves. So, although the carnival was a lot less than mediocre, it gave the four hundred black people in its audience thrill upon thrill upon thrill” (57-58).
In this passage, Denver, Paul D, and Sethe are all at a colored event carnival on a Thursday night. They are attempting to live a new life and start being happy. In their efforts, they encounter remarks made by white men in the carnival. While it is offensive, they consider it irrelevant in comparison to the amount of fun they had that night. In addition, the experience of seeing “white folks” make fools of themselves makes it that much more worth it. This passage portrays power in multiple ways. It gives Sethe and her family a sense of authority for one night and allows her to realize she can dominate those who seem to have power with her thoughts.
The power at first glance is towards white people. The fact that a carnival is separately prepared for them on a Thursday night in comparison to white people shows how unimportant they are to them and the daily lives they live. Also, when Sethe and her family do go to have a good time, they end up embarrassing and shaming them as a way to remind them of their place in society. These actions alone show the tension between the two classes. However, the way Sethe takes the whole event into perspective is admirable. To her, it did not matter what insults were aimed towards her and her family. The fact that she got to see “white folks making a spectacle of themselves” was priceless. This in a way shows power over them. It shows the power of thoughts vs. actions. The value of what goes on in ones head and the intentions of others can be focused on all throughout this passage.
Although social dominance is inherently obvious, Beloved gives the reader a new perspective on what that actually means. We are able to view and appreciate the Marxist lens in a way that wasn't easily understood before.
Monday, April 6, 2015
Anchored
"But her brain was not interested in the future. Loaded with the past and hungry for more, it left her no room to imagine, let alone plan for, the next day. Exactly like that afternoon in the wild onions -- when one more step was the most she could see of the future. Other people went crazy, why couldn't she? Other people's brains stopped turned around and went on to something new, which is what must have happened to Halle. And how sweet that would have been: the two of them back at the milk shed, squatting by the churn, smashing cold, lumpy butter into their faces with not a care in the world. Feeling it slippery, sticky -- rubbing it in their hair, watching it squeeze through their fingers. What a relief to stop it right there. Close. Shut. Squeeze the butter. But her three children were chewing sugar teat under a blanket on their way to Ohio and no butter play would change that" (83).
We are immersed in the passage of time. Sometimes we can feel the current moving. Sometimes we forget it's there, only to be reminded again. Another in a series of passing moments. A moment is defined by its momentum, it keeps moving. But we think of a memory as somehow dead, a memorial anchored in its own time and place. A half-buried reminder of what was once here. We cannot just hang onto things. We have to let go. We have to move on. Its hard to imagine that certain memories are still alive, still fighting against the current, struggling to keep up. That certain images still have the power to leap back into the present.
In this moment, Sethe is consumed by horrific images and memories of her past. When she hears Paul D tell the story of her husband watching her in the barn, her "rebellious" brain immediately begins to imagine it. She cannot imagine the future, but the stories of the past are vividly imagined in her head. So she sees her husband watching, impotent, while she is abused, and then she sees him by the churn, realizing that he was putting the butter on his face because he was remembering the milk that the boys took from Sethe. She dreads hearing the rest of Paul D's story.
Although she identifies herself largely by the work of her children, she cannot help but also be identified by her sexuality, both in the matter of love and sexual activity. It stops her from feeling the exuberant enjoyment of life, to delight in the minutes, the cheap raw material of ordinary time. In her own reflection, previous to the above passage, Sethe even calls her brain "greedy" for wrestling with woeful truths instead of blocking them and turning her focus toward her children. She feels deeply hurt and then hates herself for allowing the pain to be felt.
The text reveals that unlike other people, Sethe cannot stop herself from imagining and reliving the horrors of her life. Most people give in to their defenses and give up trying to talk about an experience because others are unable to relate to it, whether through envy, pity or simple foreignness; which allows it to drift away from the rest of your life story, until the memory itself feels out of place, almost mythical. Sethe however, cannot make her brain "stop" and move onto "something new". Her brain cannot "refuse" and say "No thank you" to the evils that haunt her. They are too big a part of her identity to let loose her grip.
| Joie de vivre / feeling of exuberant enjoyment of life. |
In this moment, Sethe is consumed by horrific images and memories of her past. When she hears Paul D tell the story of her husband watching her in the barn, her "rebellious" brain immediately begins to imagine it. She cannot imagine the future, but the stories of the past are vividly imagined in her head. So she sees her husband watching, impotent, while she is abused, and then she sees him by the churn, realizing that he was putting the butter on his face because he was remembering the milk that the boys took from Sethe. She dreads hearing the rest of Paul D's story.
Although she identifies herself largely by the work of her children, she cannot help but also be identified by her sexuality, both in the matter of love and sexual activity. It stops her from feeling the exuberant enjoyment of life, to delight in the minutes, the cheap raw material of ordinary time. In her own reflection, previous to the above passage, Sethe even calls her brain "greedy" for wrestling with woeful truths instead of blocking them and turning her focus toward her children. She feels deeply hurt and then hates herself for allowing the pain to be felt.
The text reveals that unlike other people, Sethe cannot stop herself from imagining and reliving the horrors of her life. Most people give in to their defenses and give up trying to talk about an experience because others are unable to relate to it, whether through envy, pity or simple foreignness; which allows it to drift away from the rest of your life story, until the memory itself feels out of place, almost mythical. Sethe however, cannot make her brain "stop" and move onto "something new". Her brain cannot "refuse" and say "No thank you" to the evils that haunt her. They are too big a part of her identity to let loose her grip.
Wednesday, April 1, 2015
Close Reading #1
On the 20th page of the book Sethe is with Paula Deen when she is baking biscuits. The phrase or words that impact the most are the metaphor like choice the author makes. The ones that stuck out to me the most is that Paul D's "cheek was pressing into the branches of her chokecherry tree", this metaphor shows lots of desires between the characters that maybe deep down they really don't want these lustful desires. Which definitely leads to internal conflicts on both of these character's sides afterwards. On Paul D's side we have his first desire for Sethe, however afterwards his desire and lust for her is gone. Paul D's hidden desires start to act up, "Paul D saw the float of her breasts and disliked it, the spread-away, flat roundness of them that he could definitely live without, never mind that downstairs he had held them as though they were the most expensive part of himself," (25). This is how Paul D felt in the inside about Sethe, he felt as though she was not the best women out there and pretty much didn't want her anymore and he could most likely live on wihtout her and simply move to another house the way he would. But, he doesn't and this is could be consider a conflict within Paul D because he knows for a fact that he can easily move on to another house and keep on living his life the regular way, yet he doesn't do so. And this is a very impacting decision to the readers and most likely to himself, because he decides to stay and be almost the men of the house, except his authority is limited due to the fact that its Sethe's home.
Sethe's conflict is different since she is dealing with more of a memory of her ex-husband Halle. Being with Paul D has reminded Sethe of her ex-husband And, this really puts Sethe in a corner thinking if she will go through the same pain and regret she went through with her last "marriage". Sethe begins to remember her first day of her married life, "Paul sighed and turned over. Sethe took the opportunity afforded by his movement to shift as well. Looking at Paul D's back she remembered that some of the corn stalks broke, folded down over Halle's back, and among the things her fingers clutched were husk and corn silk hair," (32). This memories deep inside Sethe have been awoken by the actions she has taken by Paul D and maybe for Sethe it was a bad idea to let them out since along with the memories of Sethe come even worst memories, about living back at Sweet Home and what happened to Sethe.
Sethe's conflict is different since she is dealing with more of a memory of her ex-husband Halle. Being with Paul D has reminded Sethe of her ex-husband And, this really puts Sethe in a corner thinking if she will go through the same pain and regret she went through with her last "marriage". Sethe begins to remember her first day of her married life, "Paul sighed and turned over. Sethe took the opportunity afforded by his movement to shift as well. Looking at Paul D's back she remembered that some of the corn stalks broke, folded down over Halle's back, and among the things her fingers clutched were husk and corn silk hair," (32). This memories deep inside Sethe have been awoken by the actions she has taken by Paul D and maybe for Sethe it was a bad idea to let them out since along with the memories of Sethe come even worst memories, about living back at Sweet Home and what happened to Sethe.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)