"It rained...It rained...It rained...Then he thought he was crying. Something was running down his cheeks. He lifted his hands to wipe away the tears and saw dark brown slime. Above him rivulets of mud slid through the boards of the roof. When it came down, he thought, gonna crush me like a tick bug. It happened so quickly he had no time to ponder...The water was above his ankles, flowing over the wooden plank he slept on. And then it wasn't water anymore. The ditch was caving in and mud oozed under and through the bars." (129-130)
In this passage, this is the scene where Paul D is really in a sticky situation. He is in jail in Georgia where jail featured more torture, and stricter rules than most jails have today and Paul D was put in jail for killing his teacher who was attempting to sell him into slavery. They placed him and forty-six other prisoners into these boxes that had metal bars in them and placed them in large ditches in the ground. This form of prison was very intense and if you broke a rule, or simply misspoke, you got shot in the head at point blank. This is part of the foundation of why Paul D learned not to love things that much in this world now because of things like this that are happening to Paul D and his cell mates. Paul D is essentially powerless in this situation until, it starts to rain. Not just rain, it starts to pour and pour all on the prisoners and presents the new issue that the prisoners face. Do they sit in the wet mud as it rises and slowly begins to drown them or, do they scream and yell to get someone's attention to move them. They choose to take it. But the problem isn't them drowning, it is the significance of the rain. Imagine forty-six large hungry, and beaten, and worn out African Americans all chained up together and at their wits end. Now, try to imagine them all covered in mud and dirt and filth from head to toe and now this downpour of rain is cleaning them of this filth. It draws comparisons to Noah's Arc and how God flooded the earth because there was too much sinning and bad things going on. The mud and dirt on the prisoners represented the dirt and overall filth they had to sit in for most of a day. Once the rain washed away all of the bad things the prisoners have done, Paul D was able to escape and make a zombie-like exit. Ultimately, Paul D got help from another white-man-oppressed race which were the Cherokees or Buffalo Men. This is the classic case of one victim helping another victim. In this situation, Paul D and some of the prisoners run into the trail of tears and a pack of Buffalo Men and it is interesting to see how this destroyed Native American culture and people can help out another destroyed group of people oppressed by the same group of people. This event that happened to Paul D and the 45 other prisoners reminds me of a quote I remembered that says "my enemy's enemy is my friend," in other words, the white man's enemy (Cherokees) are African-American people's friends. This passage shows me that no matter how hard people try to put a race down or show dominance, there will always be help somewhere out there in the world that will help.
Wednesday, April 29, 2015
Bigotry, Breast Milk, Bric-a-Brac, a Baby, and a Bit in "Beloved" Toni Morrison's Portrayal of Racism and Hegemony by Heather Duerre Humann is a literary analysis that focuses on viewing Beloved through a Marxist lens. It analyzes the concept of racism both in the book and in present American culture. The opinion of Heather Duerre Humann is quite clear. She believes Beloved portrays the way racism plays out and its effect on the perpetrators and victims. Racial stereotypes and white supremacy are both being discussed as one of the main focuses in Beloved, according to this analysis.
Many of the events these characters go through place them in the same oppressive situation in regards to race. Whether this is on purpose or inevitable, it adds to the problem. For example, Heather mentions the specific incident with Sethe and the schoolteacher. The schoolteacher uses scientific racism to treat Sethe like an animal basically. This creates a hostile environment and encourages racism for the other kids as well. We see all these events in Beloved that portray the horrible thing called racism. Humann is showing how it is still seen in todays culture in a different way. It reflects even up to this day because people feel a certain way towards each other. ‘Time’ did an interview with Toni Morrison in where she stated that “declarations that racism is irrelevant, over or confined to the past are premature fantasies”. I agree with this one hundred percent. Even though racism might not be as direct and apparent as it was in early America, doesn't mean its done with. Racism is still growing and alive in today’s culture. It is up to our society to change these standards.
Traumatizing Memories (Figuration of Rape and the Supernatural in Beloved)
In the novel Beloved it is haunted by awful memories and their history. Yet specifically Sethe is haunted by the memory of rape. Memories of this horrible moment is harsh to even forget. In order for Sethe to prevent this to happen to her children Sethe had killed her oldest daughter and then tried to kill Denver when she was just a baby. But thanks to Stamp Paid. he had taken Denver from Sethe. No Sethe wasn’t crazy she was doing it to protect them. She didn’t want her children to got through what she had gone through. She want her daughters to get raped and have that as a terrible memory.
This is not only a terrible memory that Sethe has but with all black women slaves. If they were to have a child of a white man they would throw them. The only reason the women do this is because they don't’ want to breastfeed or take care of a child that is a memory of traumatizing moment. But going more into Sethes situation, while she was being raped by white men, her husband was just watching. She is more disturbed that her husband saw what they were doing to her, yet he did nothing about, but to abandon Sethe.
The psychoanalytic lens has also supported the idea of haunting of awful memories. This is because memories can not be forgotten. She is living a life where she can’t forget her past. Especially because Sethe is emotionally traumatized by the raping incidents. How can you forget something like that? One can’t just get raped and forget about it the instant that it is over. That says in your head forever and one can’t do anything about it. Memories are forever. Once one is to return to the place that it happened, it just all comes back to you.
Amy [Angel] Denver: The White Knight (Blog #4)
The text I chose to read and interpret was the analyzation of Amy Denver by College Literature. This text highlighted the similarities and differences between Amy Denver and Sethe and it is now very apparent how Amy Denver is so different and it makes Amy Denver stand out in a better way compared to Sethe. When we look at the scene when Amy Denver meets Sethe in the forest and Sethe is at her weakest point, we can see the contrast that the reading highlighted after reading the text from College Literature. The contrast they pointed out was how Sethe was dirty and tired and in the middle of labor and Amy Denver showed up and majestically and in an angel-like manor, she aided Sethe and "brought her back to life" after nearly being on the cusp of passing out and possibly dying. The imagery that Toni Morrison has in Beloved during that scene is so powerful and really does paint a picture in your mind that Amy is this indentured servant who turns out to be this almost angel healer that ends up helping Sethe and Sethe repays her by naming her daughter Denver. In this instance, we see how power can be used for good, or for evil with Amy. She is a white woman who found a pregnant black woman in the middle of a forest and during these times, many readers would assume that Amy might turn Sethe in and Amy might use her power as a white person during this time period to exercise her hegemony over Sethe and place Sethe and eventually Denver back into slavery again possibly at Sweet Home. But no, she doesn't do this. Although Amy uses some derogatory words to talk to Sethe, the text by College Literature points out that Amy attempts to re-fix the broken bridge that Sethe has between her and white people in this book. After pointing out the differences in purposes between Amy and Sethe, the text moves on to how the word "Beloved" rings throughout the book. The text by College Literature discovered that "beloved" is constantly used as a noun and verb many times, and that Toni Morrison uses it in a negative and positive way. The negative way she uses it is with baby beloved, which is a baby and later an adult that haunts house 124. This proper noun use of beloved is used to show how the number "3" is missing from 124 because Sethe is missing her third child. College Literature began to explain how beloved as a noun is negative, but as a verb, it is a positive thing that wants to make a change in that world that Sethe lives in. College Literature interpreted Morrison's use of "Beloved" as a verb as the author wanting to amend the damaged relationship between whites and black. College Literature saw the word beloved and took it as be loved, and made the claim that the fact that everyone needs and searches for love and to be loved, that will bring races together. What I took from that scene of Amy and Sethe in the forest was pretty similar to what College Literature found but I noticed one thing, that it seems like throughout Sethe's hardest times, there is always an angel there to help her get through it. For example, with Amy and Sethe, Amy helped Sethe get back to being mobile and helped her deliver her baby. Shortly after, when Sethe needed to cross the river to get to Ohio, there was Stamp Paid and Ella who helped Denver as a newborn and fever ridden Sethe cross a river. After that there was Baby Suggs who was the elderly voice of wisdom that Sethe needed in her life.
Moving Forward
The book Beloved itself expresses a lot of emotions. We are exposed to multiple characters that have unique personalities. However, the character Paul D specifically tends to keep things to himself. In comparison to the other characters, he is very different in how he interacts and how he takes in his emotional experiences. In the book he refers to his heart as a tin tobacco box. This shows how his traumatic experiences have affected not only his heart but his perception of self. One of the major things I reflected on in this book is the need for perspective in the world.
The tin tobacco box is a symbol of history’s negative collective events that have been left unheard and neglected. Paul D feels like he has no other option than to hold everything in because no one wants to hear about these tragic events. It is not something people are comfortable listening to and it doesn't bring happiness. However, it needs to be heard. The tin tobacco boxes shows the effect it has on his heart. It is hurting him because each time he remembers something he adds it there and its tobacco to his heart; it harms him each time. We see this in today’s society as well. Minorities and lower class status are often underrepresented and don’t have a high influence in American politics. This is hurting us too because in order to be a true fair democracy we need multiple perspectives. We as a society have to encourage people to express their voice and not keep everything locked up for whatever reason. I have learned that reflection and expression is key to progress in any sort of way when it comes to class structure.
Self
All the characters in Beloved have been limited in what they can and can’t do. Throughout their experiences they often feel powerless. An incident that happened in Beloved that specifically stood out to me was when the school teacher said “definitions belong to the definers”. I related this back to history and how we are frequently taught in one perspective. When we learn about slavery, we study the main points of it, almost like a timeline. I remember in APUSH we learned about abolitionists and how slavery came to an end and the fight it took but we never really learned about the experience the slaves had with their owners directly. Beloved gave me a closer in depth study of it that is missing in our understanding.
Beloved is almost like a recollection of memories from the past. Even though at present time they are free, they are not mentally free. They can’t seem to overcome their experiences. They don’t know what to do. I have learned that a way social classes oppress another is mentally. Prior to my reading, I always thought oppression related back to the economics of classes but never really gave any value to interactions between them. While this is still true, I have learned that verbal connections and experiences are just as powerful and can incite just as much conflict as physical.
The only way to defeat this is to define oneself. Once you get to know yourself, you become better equipped to handle situations. Beloved’s characters are on a journey to develop themselves. I have learned that our social struggle are directly related to the formation of ones identity.
Critical Lens #1 (Motherhood in Toni Morrison’s Beloved: A Psychological Reading)
In the nineteenth century, African Americans weren’t really consider human beings but as property because if slaves we to escape the owner of the slave can go and claim her back. In this book, its seems that horrifying moment is over Sethe, a former slave, lives in Cincinnati with her daughter, Denver, Sethe had killed one of her own children. But in this case there was a good reason for it. Sethe was trying to keep her children from being slaves and she was also keep them away from slave catcher. she just didn't want her children to go through what she had been through. In the novel, Sethe had determined to be a good mother and push out passed memories. Paul D and Sethe are a couple but Denver' does not approve of a new man in their life. Later in the book a young women named Beloved, becomes part of the household 124 and things start to change. Denver will do anything to please her, but at most Denver feels lonely and rejected by Beloved.
The psychoanalytic lens has helped me to realize many hidden desires of the characters, from Sethe's desire, to what Beloved really wanted in 124. Sethe feels as though she must protect both Denver and Beloved since she considers Beloved as her own. On the hand, Denver wants to lose Beloved. But Beloved wants Sethe. She only love Sethe and nobody else. Once Beloved came into Sethe’s life, Sethe and Denver have felt attached. Sethe has considers Beloved as her own daughter and is now protecting her as well. It seems that Beloved wants everything that Sethe has like, for example, when Beloved had slept with Paul D many times and how she wants Denver to be devoted to her. Since Denver just loves Beloved she is like a friend and like a sister. Denver is just always there for Beloved when she is upset and when Sethe is gone.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

