Wednesday, April 29, 2015

Circulatory

Circulatory in Toni Morrison's Beloved" by Philip Page, explains how the trauma of individual characters is connected to, shared with, and responded to by all other characters and relating communities.

When reading Toni Morrison’s novel, Beloved, it is easy to see how readers would question the actions of her characters. Some characters display behavior that would seem barbaric and cruel to the average individual. However, when delving deeper, it is easier to see how the severity of the characters’ actions are built on the psychological repression of their pasts. These pasts are filled with the traumas of slavery, and each character has suffered in his, or her, own way.

                                                         
Page explains how all of Morrison’s characters struggle with the psychological repression of their pasts. While much of their pain stems from the horrors of slavery, it is also comes from their relationship with Sethe. Throughout the novel, Sethe suffers more psychological damage than any other character, making it logical that others would find themselves entangled in her life. Such tragedies are difficult to heal from and it is easy to see how locking away such memories would seem like the answer.  As readers, we may find it difficult to relate to Sethe’s actions. Killing her daughter was a very drastic measure to take, but because of the psychological traumas of her past, she was unable to see another solution. Parents will do almost anything to protect their children and Sethe is no exception. All of Sethe’s experiences throughout slavery are representations of life for all slaves. Morrison’s depictions of rape and abuse accurately portray the damaging effects that slavery had on those who were forced to carry its burden. While we must consider Sethe’s traumatic past, we must also look at her affects on those around her. Paul D, Denver, and Beloved all suffered because of their relationship with Sethe. Paul D becomes a victim of rape at the hands of Beloved, and his connection to Sethe is what links him to Beloved. Denver has never had the intimate connection that has long been needed in order for her life to have a sense of fulfillment. Sethe’s focus on Beloved, damages her connection with Denver, because Denver does share the same bond that she and Beloved do. Beloved suffered both physically and psychologically at the hands of Sethe, by being killed in order to ensure her protection. In doing so, she prevented Beloved from ever having a true identity. She was never able to have the connection with her mother that is necessary for child development. Beloved comes back into Sethe’s life as a grown woman, but because of her past, she still holds the mentality of a small child. Sethe’s actions create psychological repercussions for everyone who remains a part of her life. Morrison does an excellent job of portraying the horrors of slavery through her characters. It is important that we as readers understand the severity of the damage inflicted upon innocent victims. While Sethe has made those in her life victims of psychological repression, she is also a victim herself. We as readers must look at the importance of these characters’ struggles and recognize them as the collective suffering of all slaves during the most difficult of times.  


 However, the collective suffering can all be traced back to one character’s actions. Morrison’s main character, Sethe, has caused a great deal of pain to herself and to those around her. Her actions have caused others to respond, both physically and psychologically, therefore complicating their lives in accordance with hers. Sethe’s relationship with others has caused a great deal of pain, a pain that all of the novel’s characters must strive to overcome.



Sethe the mother or Sethe the Transformer? (Blog #3)

Throughout the fictional novel of Beloved by Toni Morrison, Sethe's motherly instincts have been brought to question of what has motherhood done to Sethe? And is Sethe overprotective of her children? After reading "Bigotry, Breast Milk, Bric-a-Brac, a Baby, and a Bit in "Beloved""  by the Penn State University Press, the author brought up many great points of how the power white men were given over slaves and African Americans during that time period brought ripples that reach out to future events which is essentially this day in age. Penn State interpreted many things in the text of Beloved that I didn't find myself and provides an interesting point of view of how racism and hegemony were themes that were present in the novel and in real life and Toni Morrison switched back and forth between real life and her novel when showing stereotypes of African Americans as a way of showing how these animal and barbaric actions that happened over 100 years ago still effect life today. The second point that I found that Penn State brought up was that Sethe was constantly being symbolized and compared to a a protective animal. She was "measured" for the schoolteacher's scientific purposes and had his nephews watch her instincts almost like how you would find the typical Australian hunter tracking and studying the habits and instincts of an animal it is planning on dissecting or hunting. These revelations have shed new light on how Sethe is viewed and her overall portrayal in the book. Sethe's natural motherly instincts are ones that raised questions of why is Sethe so set on protecting Denver, when she lost her youngest baby to murder, and her two sons ran away from her. When Sethe tells schoolteacher he can't perform tests and measurements on Denver in her motherly tone, it showed the true power Sethe had that was being oppressed until something very valuable was being presented. This brings me the conclusion that for some reason that is hard to find with any evidence that Sethe only had intentions on looking out for Denver as if Denver is the chosen child or the savior. I say this because why didn't Sethe use her protective net while her other children were struggling to stay with her?  The Penn State article presented claims that were very useful of how hegemony and social group dominance over other groups affected Sethe and African Americans as whole over time.  

Tuesday, April 28, 2015

To Never Let Go - Personal Reflection

In everyone's life there is a moment that is so dreadful and horrific that it is best to try to push it further and further back into your mind. When traumatized it is very natural to shut off the memory and in order to self-defense suppress the awful emotional experience. Very often is thought that this neglecting and abandoning is the best way to forget. So did Sethe and Paul D. Trying to ignore their past and avoid any confrontations related, they seeked to forget their awful memories. But forgetting is very temporary. It lasts only until the smallest event triggers the memory and then the horrible past is experienced once again sometimes ever so painful as it was.


In Beloved, the past is not only impossible to erase, it cannot be beaten back – both pervasive and intrusive, it lives in the present, and can never be fully banished. When the community as a whole confronts Beloved - the past embodied - they soon forget her "like a bad dream”. Yet, though she is “disremembered and unaccounted for”, she is never dead - “her footprints come and go, come and go” - the marks left by the “unspeakable horror and terror” of slavery can never be truly removed. 

The haunting past is further expressed in the deliberately halting narrative. The narrative is emphasized and echoed by a series of flowing interior monologues, which have often been described as the most poetical passages in the novel. These monologues, each an obvious part of the whole, each accentuating and reflecting the others, are a contrast, in their continuous, effortless, even incessant outpouring, to the fragmented plot. Sethe, Denver and Beloved’s unbroken thoughts and dreams add to the sense of immediacy and poetical lyricism.

The tragic stories of the characters in Beloved reveal to me a lesson in defenses. That you can develop as many defenses as possible, to protect you from fear and loss, but no matter what we are not invincible. We are human and we must allow ourselves to feel and understand each emotion that we might experience. 

A Child's Desire - Close Reading


"Denver finished washing the dishes and sat down at the table. Beloved, who had not moved since Sethe and Paul D left the room, sat sucking her forefinger. Denver watched her face awhile and then said, 'She likes him here.' Beloved went on probing her mouth with her finger. 'Make him go away', she said. 'She might be mad at you if he leaves'. Beloved, inserting a thumb in her mouth along with the forefinger pulled out a back tooth. There was hardly any blood, but Denver said 'Oooooh, didn’t that hurt you?' Beloved looked at the tooth and thought, This is it. Next would be her arm, her hand a toe. Pieces of her would drop maybe one at a time, maybe all at once. Or on one of those mornings before Denver woke and after Sethe left she would fly apart. It is difficult keeping her head on her neck, her legs attached to her hips when she is by herself". (157)
Throughout chapter 14, Morrison demonstrates Beloved’s development as a baby and is doing so by using significant metaphors. In the beginning of the passage, Beloved is, although it contradicts the general behavior of her current age, portrayed with a finger in her mouth as a similes and a sign of childhood. As a consequence of Sethe’s and Paul D’s renewed relationship and desire after each other, Beloved no longer is the center of attention and therefore reacts and responds in a childish way by sucking her finger. When Denver, after observing Beloved behavior once Sethe and Paul D departure from the dining room, comments that Sethe enjoys Paul D’s presence at 124, “Beloved went on probing her mouth with her finger” further and later responds with a naive answer by asking Denver to “make him go away”. Through this specific type of childlike diction, Morrison accomplishes to generalize the immature and underdeveloped behavior for young children.

However, when Denver, by saying “She might be mad at you if he leaves”, rejects Beloved’s wish of the withdrawal of Paul D from Sethe, the pressure of Beloveds fingers in her mouth becomes too hard and subsequently she loses one of her back teeth. This action shows Beloved’s development of growing up. As Beloved enter the novel in chapter 5, Beloved represent the life of an infant by demonstrating her non capability to neither walk nor talk. Losing a tooth, in Beloved’s case, is symbolic for the next step of maturing. However, by losing a tooth purposely, Beloved again shows sign of harming herself in order to get attention from Sethe. When Beloved later realizes that Denver, her sister, admirer and support, will not participate in the wish of excluding Paul D, she understands that without Sethe (and Denver to an extent) “It is difficult keeping her head on her neck, her legs attached to her hips when she is by herself”. The progress of learning to accept your mistakes and gaining beneficial knowledge by learning not to repeat them seems to become reasonable to Beloved. In order not to lose Sethe and Denver Beloved understands that she must learn how to respect others individual in her surroundings.

Regardless of how harmful Beloveds actions might seem towards herself as well as the individuals in her surroundings, this only proofs and confirms 
her constant development and growing as a human, the progress from an infant to a pre teenager, trapped in a adults body. It is a natural tendency for children, just as Beloved does, to use an immature, unsecure and dependent behavior in order to satisfy their need of attention. However, as individuals mature these factors disappears with time, only so because of comprehending the importance of being able to be your own individual and stand on your own feet.

Remembrance, progress and respect

“It was not a story to pass on.

They forgot her like a bad dream. After they made up their tales, shaped and decorated them, those that saw her that day on the porch quickly and deliberately forgot her. It took longer for those who had spoken to her, lived with her, fallen in love with her, to forget, until they realized they couldn’t remember or repeat a single thing she said, and began to believe that, other than what they themselves were thinking, she hadn’t said anything at all. So, in the end, they forgot her too. Remembering seemed unwise…

It was not a story to pass on” (323-324).



Beloved is referred to as a “bad dream”. As a result, people want to forget her and live life as if she never appeared. They have convinced themselves that she is a blank memory and nothing more. After all, all Beloved does is bring back horrid flashbacks to Sethe. In order to be a peace and comfortable with their lives, Beloved has to be forgotten, completely shut out. However, Beloved cannot be. It is a symbol in this book for a greater theme in America’s history and socioeconomic conditions.

Beloved represents hatred, slavery, denial and much more. Yet all this chapter does is express how much it wants to put away this reminder in a sense. At the end of the book, the phrase “It was not a story to pass on” is repeated three times throughout. It emphasizes the want to forget about America’s past and move forward. However, in order to move forward, we have to acknowledge and remember the past, no matter how painful it might be. The past connects to our present. The socioeconomic history and patterns of this country speak for themselves. The relationships and tensions between social classes and racial ethnicities are evident. They relate back to a bigger issue in America. Beloved serves as a reminder that oppression is real and has to be addressed. It may be an uncomfortable topic to discuss but one that needs to nevertheless. The final ending says a lot about today’s struggle while also doing a great job of honoring past struggles.

Loss

“Singing love songs to Mr.Death, they smashed his head. More than the rest, they killed the flirt whom folks called Life for leading them on. Making them think the next sunrise would be worth it; that another stroke of time would do it at last. Only when she was dead would they be safe. The successful ones-- the ones who had been there enough years to have maimed, mutilated, maybe even buried her-- kept watch over the others who were still in her cock-teasing hug, caring and looking forward, remembering and looking back” (128).

In this passage, Paul D is remembering the horrors of the time where he was sent to prison in Georgia for the attempted murder of Brandywine. This was one of the darkest time periods in his life. In addition, Paul D personifies the idea of life and finds himself fighting it. He sees it as an evil thing that mimics him and everyone around. He goes on to show that the only way out was “when she was dead”. This clearly results in death and is basically what he wanted at that point of his life.

Paul D experiences alone show that it wasn’t just physical abuse that was going on, but mental abuse as well. It was another form of oppression that one could say is even worse and leaves a long term impact on a person. We see Paul D having flashbacks of this and how it still affects him even as a freed man. This begins to uncover the impacts of societal conditions one is placed in. Paul D in a sense starts to rethink his morals and beliefs. This symbolizes a complete defeat in a person. You can beat and verbally abuse someone but if no reaction is made and they stand strong, they have beaten you but the moment you start to rethink who you are and what you stand for, you have been beaten and the battle is lost. This happened to Paul D. They broke him to the point where he changes his whole mindset about life. A desire was ripped out of his life that has affected him severely. Its another type of dominance that is portrayed in Beloved, something much more than socioeconomic. The true power of a class over another remains in one's reactions.

The True Goal ( Slavery and Motherhood in Toni Morrison's Beloved)

       Throughout the story Beloved seems to really want to get attached to Sethe, but what is the reason behind this? Sethe had no idea why did Beloved come to specifically 124, but when she heard her name her body reacted suddenly and abruptly. And she suddenly begin to feel like this person should have been with her for a long time. Beloved had a reason behind this scheme of hers, which was to obtain what she had lost. In the case of the book she says that Sethe is her face and that she lost that face but has now found it and can be reunited with it once more. In the reading Slavery and motherhood in Toni Morrison's Beloved that is about many different things, however the main thing that stood out to me was motherhood and the symbol of it, which explains about this phase that happens in the book which is basically Beloved's fantasy of fusing with her so called "mother". This indeed occurs, but it does so in a strange way where Sethe is being shrunken while Beloved is becoming more of Sethe's mother and Sethe is being taken care of by Beloved. Beloved made this happen by draining Sethe's energy and forced Sethe to become more dependent, while Beloved stealing Sethe's life became more of a wome, and a mom.
     
      Looking at this through the psychoanalytical lens, we can clearly see what were Beloved's through desires and motivations. Which are not really shown, until towards the end when Paul D left. And maybe Beloved had sex with Paul D in order for Paul D to freak out and make him leave the house, that way Sethe was going to be all for Beloved. This lead to her true desires of obtaining what she had lost which was pretty much Sethe. By being alone with Sethe and nobody to grab Sethe's attention, she was able to get her face back and to be able to see and smile the way Beloved wanted to from the begging that she arrived at 124. Looking at this book through the psychoanalytical lens, has allowed for a deeper understanding of what characters were thinking, what were their intentions, what were some of the conflicts that the characters had whether that was internal or external and this helped me to realize the way Beloved was and maybe even what the meaning of Beloved in this book was.